PDA

View Full Version : [Gadgets] Zune HD


GlassAdam
10-01-2010, 08:47 PM
http://i59.photobucket.com/albums/g306/glassadam/zune-hd.jpg
I hemmed and hawed for some time about buying a Zune HD, but finally decided to pull the trigger and am very happy I did. I have no love for Apple products so that was never an option, and Sony's X-series touchscreen Walkman failed to impress me when it was released. Older Zunes were never on my radar, but the Zune HD caught my eye from the get-go and never let up. The only thing holding me back was the cost (it is pretty expensive) but two months ago I decided to splurge and haven't regretted it.

For a bit of background context, I should mention that I use the Zune HD daily, both in my Jeep and at work. By the way, I work a very physical job in a warehouse and was worried that the player wouldn't be able to stand up to all the action, but I've had no problems there-- no scratched or cracked screen (thank goodness), no other physical damage at all. This thing's stronger than I expected!

Anyway, the player itself is great. The OLED screen is crisp and colorful, just really pleasing to look at. The touch sensitivity is top-notch, and the user interface is fun to use, intuitive, stylish, and things that I expect to happen just happen (all the usual pinch-to-zoom and such is supported and works well). I suppose I would recommend watching a youtube video or a review video in order to get a basic handle on how the UI works, because it's not really like any other player, and certainly doesn't fit in with the practical-yet-bland "screen full of icons" approach popularized by Apple. As far as playing music goes, the sound is great for my needs (but I should note that I'm no audiophile), though I wish it could get louder. All in all, the player works fantastically, and I really couldn't be happier with it's performance.

If you're looking for apps you should probably look elsewhere. There are a few apps and a few games but it's pretty clear this isn't a big priority for Microsoft. I'm sure they'll step it up for the next Zune now that they're releasing Windows Phone 7 (which borrows very heavily from the Zune HD), but for now, on this model, the app store is pretty light in content. I didn't buy this for apps, though, I bought it to be a media player, and in that regard it's an absolute beast, so there you have it.

You can access the internet via wifi, and while this is a nice feature to have, it really isn't all that useful to me since I carry a smartphone with a much better web browser (Palm Pre).

I couldn't fairly review this player without also going into it's desktop syncing software. Simply put, it's phenomenal. It blows away iTunes as far as I'm concerned in many ways which I won't really get into here. I will say that it keeps up the theme of beauty and functionality present in the player itself. Microsoft has created an entire ecosystem with the Zune HD and the Zune software that just works really, really well. Oh yeah, there is a social aspect present too, where you can keep track of your Zune Friends, see what they've been listening to, and listen to it yourself.

Speaking of listening to music, you really ought to do yourself a favor and subscribe to the Zune Pass. For just 15 dollars a month you can download as much music as you want for up to, I think, 3 Zune devices. Make no mistake-- this is a subscription service. So if you quit paying the fee, you lose access to all that music you downloaded. Think of it like Netflix for your mp3 player, I guess. On the other hand, you get to choose 10 songs per month that you keep forever, DRM free, so in reality the subscription only costs five bucks. And the desktop software acts as another way to listen to all the millions of songs in Zune's library of music, sort of like the ultimate lovechild of iTunes, Pandora, and Grooveshark (but better-looking and easier to use than any of those programs). Oh, and they have movies on the Zune marketplace, too.
http://i59.photobucket.com/albums/g306/glassadam/zunehdblog2.png
Pros:

The sleek, stylish and responsive user interface. I'm a sucker for pretty-yet-functional UIs.
Sound quality is great to my ears
It's a little thing, but I love how the music automatically pauses when I pull the auxiliary cord or headphone cord out of it.
The industrial design is tremendous. The player is lightweight, but feels great in hand. It looks stylish unlike many other mp3 players, including Apple's iPod (in my opinion, but this is of course very subjective).


Cons:

No physical volume button. This is an odd choice, and the single most inconvenient/annoying thing about the player. You can get past it, but you shouldn't have to.
No AM radio
internet browsing kinda sucks
lack of apps
software keyboard isn't too great
wish the max volume were a bit higher
plugging the Zune HD into my XBox 360 doesn't work as great as expected; it takes FOREVER for the 360 to see the songs and let me play 'em. It should take seconds, not 4-7 minutes! (this may be a 360 issue, though, I'm not sure)


Other (probably pretty cool) features that I don't use so haven't factored into my review:

HD radio
720p HD video output


All in all I love this mp3 player. This isn't some glowing review on Day 1 after purchase based on only a few hours of use... I've put in a LOT of time with this thing and I still love it. Do yourself a favor and don't dismiss this player just because you haven't heard of it or just because it's Microsoft. It really is fantastic. Get one now. Do it.

Grand_OoF
10-01-2010, 09:04 PM
Very, very well done. I currently have an MP3 player (Sandisk Sansa) which, in spite of a cracked screen, does the job quite well, but I have to admit as someone generally against the iStuff (though I do think the iPad is kinda cool...still wouldn't PAY for one though...) I am glad to hear this is a nice alternative. And the monthly service sounds like a good deal too.

How much does the HD Zune cost?

Anyway, excellent review.

GlassAdam
10-01-2010, 09:09 PM
Thanks for the kind words!

The Zune HD comes in a range of prices, depending on how much memory you want. Amazon has it listed as follows:

16gb: $199.99 $160.43
32gb: $269.99 $204.99
64gb: $349.99 $334.78

You can also order directly from MS' website and pay a bit extra for engravings on the back, such as text and/or illustrations.

KomodoAce
10-01-2010, 09:31 PM
Oooh great review. I'm actually in the market once again for a new mp3 player after my Sansa's left channel failed (I abuse the shit out of my mp3 players and will be buying protection for my next mp3 player).

My question is how long the battery power is for having the device play music/video and going on the internet.

Would you say it's more difficult to go on the internet than the PSP?

RedWizard
10-01-2010, 09:38 PM
Hmm. A Zune HD huh? if I had spare cash I would probably get one myself. Except, well, I don't have a lot of digital music (aside from videogame OSTs). And I can't really imagine forking over $15/month just to listen to music (when I already have it on another format, anyway). But, that all does seem very tempting, very tempting indeed...

Still, I'm still using one of these, and I can't really fathom gettin rid of it:

http://img299.imageshack.us/img299/8797/sonywalkmancassette2.jpg (http://img299.imageshack.us/i/sonywalkmancassette2.jpg/)

GlassAdam
10-01-2010, 09:44 PM
Oooh great review. I'm actually in the market once again for a new mp3 player after my Sansa's left channel failed (I abuse the shit out of my mp3 players and will be buying protection for my next mp3 player).

My question is how long the battery power is for having the device play music/video and going on the internet.

Would you say it's more difficult to go on the internet than the PSP?Battery Power: When listening to music the battery lasts a looooong time. I've gone a couple days between charges, and I can be using the thing for up to 10 hours a day. Using the internet via wifi, on the other hand, sucks down the battery at a pretty good clip, as you would imagine. Same with playing games. So I imagine that if you're watching a lot of videos/movies on it, you'll need a charge at least every night.

As for the internet browsing experience: First off, I've never used a PSP, so I can't compare the two. What I have used are smartphone web browsers, and I have to say that I much prefer the browser on my phone. There's nothing wrong with the HD's browser, I guess, but it just can't compare to the refined experience on most modern cellphones. It loads slower (even over wifi) than my phone, and it can't access YouTube videos. But it formats sites correctly, for the most part, in my experience. I've browsed Foxkei on it, for example.

If you're looking for apps/games/youtube, I'll be honest, you might be better off with an iPod Touch. But if you're more focused on music and movies, you're better off with the Zune HD. Why the distinction for movies? Simple-- the Zune HD's OLED screen. It's far superior to anything else out there aside from Sony's X-series Walkman (also sporting an OLED screen). It's just a crisper, more vibrant screen. And it sips less battery than a normal screen, which is always nice.

KomodoAce
10-01-2010, 09:50 PM
I'm more focused on movies/music and I don't care for apps.

I ask about the internet since I'd love to be at work and be able to go to foxkei and reddit. Also use the chat in Yahoo mail.

The battery power sounds decent. I wish it was more but I'm almost never away from a computer so it's not too big of a deal.

I kinda prefer flash memory so I can drag & drop music/video files but you make it sound like the Zune software makes the transfer of files relatively painless.

GlassAdam
10-02-2010, 12:08 AM
I'm more focused on movies/music and I don't care for apps.

I ask about the internet since I'd love to be at work and be able to go to foxkei and reddit. Also use the chat in Yahoo mail.

The battery power sounds decent. I wish it was more but I'm almost never away from a computer so it's not too big of a deal.

I kinda prefer flash memory so I can drag & drop music/video files but you make it sound like the Zune software makes the transfer of files relatively painless.

To be honest, Komodo, if you're looking for a great browsing experience, you should probably look elsewhere. This is more of an "in-a-pinch" type browsing experience, where you might only choose to use it if nothing else is available. For one thing, the smallish screen size is great for viewing photos and movies, but not so great for typing on the virtual keyboard. And the browser often defaults to mobile sites instead of full sites (I actually prefer mobile sites on a small device, but some people don't). It can do full sites, but like I said, it's not the default. Also, it's not capable of rich internet content, such as flash video (youtube). I tried to get to chat on my Yahoo mail account but it wasn't available (I'm not even sure you can do Yahoo Mail Chat on smartphones, FWIW). So if you're hoping for this type of stuff you'll be out of luck.

As for drag-and-drop: I used to be the same way, and indeed, when I used a Walkman, that's all that was available. I thought drag-and-drop was what I wanted/preferred. Then I discovered the beauty of a well-organized collection, cleaned up all my metatagging, and live in harmony with automatically syncing my player without having to think about it. It really is great and I can honestly say that it's a lot easier and I prefer the software-syncing method. And hell, you can always choose which individual songs/pics/vids to put on the player (or take off of it) one-by-one on your own at any time so it's not too different if you really want to go that route. One thing I would recommend doing is downloading the Zune software to your PC and trying it out for a while (it's free). Get a feel for it and see if you like it. That's what I did before I bought the player, just to make sure it was right for me. It makes ripping, burning, and creating playlists easy, and there's also a large emphasis on finding new music if that's your bag.

One other thing that I didn't mention in the review but is something to consider: the Zune HD has no external speaker. So if you wanna hear anything you need to use headphones or hook it up to a stereo or something else.

If you have any more questions I'll be happy to answer them. I guess I've turned into something of a Zune evangelist... I just love the damn thing! :D

KomodoAce
10-02-2010, 12:19 AM
No more questions. Thanks for the info. I'll look into it and maybe when I get my next paycheck, I'll get one. The internet thing is more of a "bonus" to me so it's not that really a big deal to me. I'm just interested in the music sounding good and the file transfer.

GlassAdam
10-02-2010, 12:24 AM
I downloaded the Zune software to try it, like I said, and it was cool but the animation was stiff and not very impressive. I went into Settings and it said that my PC wasn't powerful enough for the advanced graphical awesomeness. Well fuck that, I thought, and I set it to max graphical acceleration anyway. And by golly, it worked fine, and now it looks and animates sexy as hell.

Umbrae
10-02-2010, 11:13 PM
Ah, glad to hear you're content with your purchase.

It baffles me when I see every PMP vendor tries to copy Apple and their iPod Touch products. Most of us have multiple devices (smart-phones, netbooks, laptops, pads, etc), so we don't need the same functionality in all the devices.

When I buy an MP3 player, I want it to play music and perhaps movies. That's it! No need for apps or games or browser; I can get those on my smart-phone! Or my laptop.

I think Microsoft ans Sony are smart for realizing this. Their devices are stylish and do what you'd expect them to do: play music!

I'm happy with my purchase (http://www.foxkei.com/blog/487/misc/me/sony-walkman-x-series/) even though I dropped it on concrete once and the screen cracked. everything still works, but the sexiness is gone. So that's why I was wondering how well your device withstands physical abuse.

GlassAdam
10-04-2010, 02:02 AM
Ah, glad to hear you're content with your purchase.

It baffles me when I see every PMP vendor tries to copy Apple and their iPod Touch products. Most of us have multiple devices (smart-phones, netbooks, laptops, pads, etc), so we don't need the same functionality in all the devices.

When I buy an MP3 player, I want it to play music and perhaps movies. That's it! No need for apps or games or browser; I can get those on my smart-phone! Or my laptop.

I think Microsoft ans Sony are smart for realizing this. Their devices are stylish and do what you'd expect them to do: play music!

I'm happy with my purchase (http://www.foxkei.com/blog/487/misc/me/sony-walkman-x-series/) even though I dropped it on concrete once and the screen cracked. everything still works, but the sexiness is gone. So that's why I was wondering how well your device withstands physical abuse.

Agree. And as for the durability of the player, well like I said it's kept up with me at my job. But I'm sure if I dropped it on concrete like you did it would probably be the same story. It is a glass screen, after all. :\